| Player | Years Played |
|---|---|
| Buz Burnside | 19 |
| Taylor Burnside | 19 |
| Robert Oakley | 19 |
| Hannes Schindler | 19 |
| Ryan Oakley | 18 |
| Roger Mellor | 17 |
| Jarvis Nicoll | 17 |
| Tibor Guban | 16 |
| Jason Backs | 15 |
| John Mellor | 15 |
| Matt Horton | 11 |
| Randy Oakley | 11 |
| Brad Laufer | 10 |
| Marcus Head | 7 |
| David Gradwohl | 6 |
| Randy Just | 5 |
| Toby Arrowsmith | 3 |
| Archer Oakley | 3 |
| Brian Powell | 3 |
| Josh Baymiller | 2 |
| Eric Dunkel | 2 |
| Rob Kozlowski | 2 |
| Cooper Peloso | 2 |
| Derek Sepesy | 2 |
| Patrick Sweetser | 2 |
| Damon Vanderhoff | 2 |
| Craig Bloom | 1 |
| Chad Boss | 1 |
| Andrew Coworker | 1 |
| Ryan Harris | 1 |
| Tyler Horton | 1 |
| Cillian Irishman | 1 |
| Scott Jolley | 1 |
| Ty Jones | 1 |
| Mike McDonald | 1 |
| Carson Nicoll | 1 |
| John Oakley | 1 |
| Nick Saar | 1 |
| Davey Zaleschuk | 1 |